The movie begins oddly, with a shot of a staircase, and hearing lots of yelling, such as "Let me go, Dolores!" The shadows tell us there is a struggle at the top of the stairs, and soon after, an elderly lady in a nightgown topples down the stairs fatally. Kathy Bates, Dolores Claiborne, then follows and runs to the kitchen, frantically looking for something. Picking up a rolling pin, she hurries back and looks about to smash the old lady in the face (who is still, just barely, alive), when the mail man comes in and stops her, then discovering the old lady died.
Then switch to Jennifer Jason Leigh's character, Selina, who is arguing with her boss about an apparent journalist job or something. She gets a fax about the "murder" of the old lady and the association with her mom. She travels back to her hometown (I can't recall where it is...) and bails her mom out (not of jail), and they head back to their old house, a run-down, tattering house with graffiti and broken windows and etc all over it. We've learned by now that Dolores was working for the old lady as her housekeeper, and this is an usual case because, like, 20 years earlier, she'd been accused of murdering her husband, and found innocent. Dolores isn't all that well liked in the town...
Selina is not a pleasant person. She apparently despises her mother, drinks and smokes, pops about a thousand pills. Seriously, like Dolores pulls out about 8 different pill thingies from her suit case ("thanks for going through my stuff, mom.."). They settle into the house and Dolores is visited by many different memories. She begins to reintroduce Selina to their past, revealing different things, like how her husband, Selina's father, had beat her severly and treated her terrible. The whole movie starts into a split-story between the present day investigation into Vera (the old lady)'s death and a telling of the secrets of the past. Selina refuses to believe many of the terrible things she learns about her father, and Dolores is ever more disturbed by memories. A jerk-ass cop/detective is intent on sending Dolores to jail for murder, as he failed in the past at locking her up to do with the husband's death. The further we get into the movie, the more it looks like Dolores didn't murder Vera at all. She tells Selina how it all really happened: Vera, very old and decrepete Anyway, despite how boring my summary is, this movie was good. The twists and the split between present and past was very drawing and a neat technique. After watching it, I did, though, have a hard time picturing this being a Stephen King book. There were possibly a few suspenseful moments, but mostly, it was just interesting and dramatic. I'm interested to read the book now, to see if it's usual Stephen King or what. o.o
What I liked:A lot of stuff, actually. ^^;; Umm.. I'll start with the actors. All very good. Until seeing this movie, I could only see Kathy Bates as the infamous Molly Brown in Titanic, but this changed it. She delivered a wonderful performance, as I knew she would, but her character was completely different from the stereotypical Molly I saw her as. It was a nice awakening. She was great in all aspects, the present and the past, very good.
I did like the characterization too. This is a great example of how past-to-present mental problems should be presented. You wonder exactly what makes Selina so screwed up, and instead of shoving it all in your face at once so it seems like a sham, it very slowly, very subtly brings to present the realistic, terrible things that happened to her that make her exactly how she is. It was so believable.... people could take a good cue from this director on how to establish that. Every character was like, in fact, except for the ones you have no connection enough to to learn. They all had something quirky and screwed up to them, and almost all of it was revealed in a nice, soft way that makes you go, "Ooh... my god.." I really liked that, and that may partly come from Stephen King being the original creator of this, since he's a God at characterization.
This is pretty related, but I LOVED the past-present relationship. The way they did everything about that was great. For one, the actors they got to portray younger versions of the people, or the actor themselves, was amazing. Young Selina doesn't look like a mini-me version of Jennifer Jason Leigh, but she looks remarkably like she would have grown into her. Kathy Bate's ageing process is so good, it's amazing. She goes from looking fairly young and still pretty, and they introduce the reasons she looks to old in relation to a shot of her older, and it's just great. All the others, they must have had GREAT make-up jobs, like Vera, who goes from being middle-aged to really old and such, the same with the jerk-ass cop. They intertwined the past in a nice way, except for one instance, when it's Selina having the memory, and she looks next to her and sees her father, and I was like, "SHIT! Is he still alive?" of course, it's only a memory, but it was confusing. @.@ I liked other stuff, but I've gotta move on.
Stuff I didn't like: Lessee... their accents. o.o >.o Kay, that's kind of prejudice. No, I seriously thought they were Southern, and then they start speaking in these really weird accents.. @.@ I suppose it would help to remember where the movie takes place, but I can't. =/ Selina drives from New York, so it's gotta be the East somewhere. It does sound like an Eastern accent. It caught me off guard, and I just didn't like it. =/
It did tend to drag at times, but I can't say when. There were just some parts where I found my attention drifting.
Well.. I dunno.. I'm sure there was more I didn't like, or else this would be a perfect movie, and it wasn't, but you know, I can't think up much more. @.o Maybe I'm getting tired. And hungry. *noddles, goes off to get food*
I was a little leery of Jennifer Jason Leigh, after watching only the first half of Existenz and being so turned off by the hash of a movie, but I was willing to give her another chance, on the idea that she was just given a bad script and movie. After all, Jude (Law) was in it (Existenz, not DC), and I love every other movie of his I've seen. I'm glad I did. She was pretty good in this (looking great as a brunette. ^~), though her grin seemed a little off at times. She was great as the destroyed, alcoholic smoker forced to confront her past, and I liked her in it.
Everyone else was good, the dad especially. MAN was he disgusting. You sure hated him, and that's great. ^_^ Kudos to whoever that was.